In a high-speed blender add all ingredients, except for the liquors. Blend on high-speed for a few minutes. Taste the coquito to adjust the flavors as desired. This is the time for adding more spices or maple syrup if you would like to add more sweetener to your coquito.
Add white rum, coconut rum, and brandy if using. Pour your coquito inside a sealed bottle or jug. Add a cinnamon stick to the jar if desired. Chill overnight or at least for 4 to 6 hours.
Before serving your coquito, shake/stir to incorporate ingredients. Serve and garnish with a cinnamon stick and coconut flakes.
Video
Notes
You can use this recipe as the base for other coquito flavors. I divided this recipe and added pistachio ice cream, pistachio extract, and chopped pistachios.
Scan the QR code to come back to the The Hungry Dragonfly for more tips and FAQs!